Key Takeaways
- Cin Cin holds Brighton's only Michelin Bib Gourmand for Italian
- Pinocchio does two courses for £16.95 before the theatre
- Fatto a Mano keeps most tables for walk-ins and queues at weekends
- Semola has 22 seats — book or miss out
- IL Bistro has been open since 1976 and does £10 pasta lunches
Italian Restaurants in Brighton
Brighton has always had a thing for Italian food. The city has dozens of Italian restaurants, and most of them are fine. Some of them are very good. One of them holds a Michelin Bib Gourmand and has kept it for nine years running. That wasn’t the case when we last wrote this guide, and it changes the picture.
The Italian scene here splits into three lanes. There’s the new wave: seasonal small plates, monthly-changing menus, chefs who’ve worked in London’s best kitchens. There are the trattorias: family-run, decades-old, more interested in feeding you well than impressing food critics. And there’s pizza, which Brighton takes more seriously than most cities twice its size. This guide covers all three.
| Venue | Area | Price | Best For | Book? | Fresh Pasta? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cin Cin | Hove | ££-£££ | Bib Gourmand, date night | Yes | Yes |
| Tutto | City Centre | £££ | Occasion, wood-fire grill | Yes | Yes |
| La Tana | Patcham | ££ | Seasonal, neighbourhood | Yes | Yes |
| Pinocchio | North Laine | £-££ | Pre-theatre, value | Yes | Yes |
| Donatello | The Lanes | £-££ | Families, groups | Yes | Yes |
| Franco’s Osteria | Hove | ££-£££ | Sharing, intimate | Yes | Yes (all on-site) |
| IL Bistro | The Lanes | ££ | Heritage, £10 lunch | Yes | Yes |
| Semola | Hove | ££ | Pasta purist, Pinsa | Yes | Yes (all on-site) |
| Al Duomo | City Centre | ££ | Pre-theatre, outdoor | Yes | Yes |
| Fatto a Mano | 3 branches | ££ | Neapolitan pizza | Yes (groups) | N/A |
| Purezza | Kemptown | ££ | Vegan pizza | Walk-in | N/A |
| Franco Manca | City Centre | £ | Budget pizza | Yes | N/A |
The Standouts
Cin Cin

Cin Cin on Western Road in Hove has held a Michelin Bib Gourmand since September 2018. It also has an AA Rosette and finished in the BRAVO top 10 for 2025. For an Italian restaurant that started life selling pasta from a vintage Fiat van at Brighton’s street food markets, that trajectory is remarkable.
The menu changes monthly, built around what’s seasonal. Small plates and handmade pasta. The open kitchen and counter seating mean you eat watching the cooks work, which adds to the evening. The Chef’s Menu runs to five courses with an optional wine flight. A midweek deal on Wednesdays and Thursdays gets you three courses and a carafe for two. Dog-friendly. Gluten-free options. The courtyard opens in warmer months. If you eat Italian in Brighton once, eat here.
Tutto

Tutto occupies a restored 1930s Grade II-listed banking hall on Marlborough Place. High ceilings, Art Deco bones, amber lighting. It comes from the Black Rock group, the same people behind The Salt Room and Burnt Orange. BRAVO put it in the top 10 for best lunch in Brighton in 2025.
The kitchen uses a wood-fire grill for fish and meat alongside classic pasta and rice dishes. A standalone plant-based menu means vegans get proper attention, not a token option. The Italian wine list runs north to south by region. A 34-seat terrace faces Victoria Gardens. The room is the draw for a special evening. The food keeps up.
La Tana
La Tana is in Patcham, a ten-minute drive north of the city centre. It has been family-owned since 2012 and people in the neighbourhood treat it like their kitchen. Hot stone steaks are a signature alongside the Italian staples. The cocktails are better than you’d expect from a suburban restaurant. Worth the trip if you want Italian food without the Lanes crowds, and it works well as a date night spot.
The Trattorias
Pinocchio

Pinocchio on New Road has been feeding North Laine since 1987. Sardinian-born Pietro Addis opened it. His sons Leo, Stefano, and Mikele run it now. The set menu starts at £16.95 for two courses, which still makes it one of the better-value Italian meals in the city centre. Recently redecorated throughout, with a new kitchen and redesigned upstairs. Pre-theatre is the sweet spot. Sister restaurant to Donatello in the Lanes.
Donatello
Donatello on Brighton Place has grown from a 100-seater to over 300 covers, which makes it one of the largest Italian restaurants in the city. Same Addis family (Pietro opened this one in 1991). Fixed-price menu from £16.95 for two courses. Cooking at that scale is not always consistent, but for families and large groups needing a reliable meal at a fair price in the Lanes, it does the job. Outdoor seating opposite the Pavilion in summer.
Franco’s Osteria
Franco’s Osteria on Victoria Terrace, on the Hove seafront, does something most Brighton Italians don’t: a true osteria sharing format. Antipasti, pasta, secondi, dessert, all placed in the middle of the table for the group. Set sharing menu runs around £35 per person. Franco works the floor most nights. All pasta and bread made on-site. The wine list is Franco’s own selection. Chunky wooden tables, exposed brick, a small dining room. The kind of Italian meal where you don’t order for yourself.
IL Bistro

IL Bistro has been open since 1976. That makes it Brighton’s longest-running independent restaurant. The building is an 18th-century fisherman’s cottage in the Lanes. BRAVO gave it Best International Cuisine and Best Team in 2025. The weekend pasta lunch deal is £10 including a glass of wine, which is absurd value for a Lanes restaurant. Second-generation now: founder Michael Garman’s son Abe runs it. The menu leans Mediterranean steakhouse as much as Italian, with dry-aged British beef alongside fresh pasta. But the heritage and the lunch deal earn it a place here.
Semola

Semola on Church Road has 22 seats. Book or you won’t get in. Run by Roberto and Luca, cooking the fresh pasta and simple dishes they grew up with in Milan and Puglia. The name means “semolina” and the menu lives up to it: they use multiple types of semolina flour, each chosen for a different texture and flavour. One of the only places in Brighton doing Pinsa Romana, the lighter, crispier ancestor of pizza. Won Best Homemade Pasta at the Italian Awards in 2017. The pasta purist’s pick.
Al Duomo
Al Duomo on Pavilion Buildings has been going since 1979. Dino Azzaroni opened it and installed Brighton’s first wood-fired pizza oven. It seats 300, which means you can usually get a table without booking. An express lunch (starter and main, £18, Monday to Friday noon to 3pm) and a theatre menu (two courses £22, three for £25, Monday to Friday 5pm to 7pm) keep prices reasonable for the location. The outdoor terrace faces the Royal Pavilion. A crowd-pleaser rather than a destination, but solid for what it does.
Pizza
Brighton’s pizza scene deserves its own guide, and it has one. The quick version:
Fatto a Mano is the standard-bearer. Mostly walk-in across all three branches, though North Laine takes online bookings for groups of up to 16 (North Laine, Hove, Preston Circus). Neapolitan dough, quality toppings, queues at peak times. Founded in Brighton in 2015, now celebrating ten years. Kids eat free (under 12, one per paying adult). Margherita runs about £15.50.
Purezza on St James’s Street in Kemptown is the UK’s first vegan pizzeria. The brown rice mozzarella is the star. Even non-vegans leave impressed. National Pizza of the Year winner. The Hove branch has closed, so Kemptown is the one.
Franco Manca does what it does everywhere: reliable sourdough pizza at prices that undercut most independents. Good for a quick, no-fuss lunch. See our full pizza guide for more options.
Practical Tips
Brighton Insider tip: The set menus are where the value is. Pinocchio, Donatello and Al Duomo all run fixed-price lunch or pre-theatre deals that land well under their a la carte prices, and all three sit within five minutes of the Theatre Royal.
Booking
Cin Cin, Tutto, Semola, and Franco’s Osteria all need booking, especially at weekends. Fatto a Mano keeps most of its tables for walk-ins, though the North Laine branch books groups of up to 16 online. Pinocchio and IL Bistro take reservations and it’s worth using them for pre-theatre.
Best Value
Pinocchio and Donatello both do two courses for £16.95. Franco Manca is the cheapest pizza, with a lunch deal at £12.50. Al Duomo’s express lunch (£18 for a starter and main, Monday to Friday) works for the Pavilion end of town.
Vegetarian and Vegan
Purezza is fully vegan. Tutto has a standalone plant-based menu. Cin Cin and Semola offer gluten-free and vegetarian options as standard. Most trattorias have at least a couple of veggie pasta dishes.
Best for Groups
Donatello seats over 300 and handles large bookings. Franco’s Osteria’s sharing format is designed for groups of 4-8. Tutto’s banking hall has the space and atmosphere for celebrations.
Where to Sit
Cin Cin’s counter seats overlooking the kitchen are the best in the city. Tutto’s terrace faces Victoria Gardens. Al Duomo’s outdoor tables face the Royal Pavilion. In summer, all three are hard to beat.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best Italian restaurant in Brighton?
Cin Cin in Hove holds a Michelin Bib Gourmand and has done for nine years. It’s the highest-formally-recognised Italian in the city. For a more traditional trattoria experience, Pinocchio and IL Bistro are the institutions.
Where is the best pasta in Brighton?
Semola on Church Road in Hove is the pasta specialist, using multiple semolina flours and making everything on-site. Cin Cin’s monthly-changing handmade pasta dishes are also outstanding. Franco’s Osteria makes all pasta and bread in-house.
Is Brighton good for pizza?
Very. Fatto a Mano has three branches and queues to prove it. Purezza does the best vegan pizza in the UK. Franco Manca is reliable and cheap. See our pizza guide for the full picture.
What is the cheapest Italian food in Brighton?
Pinocchio’s set menu starts at £16.95 for two courses and Donatello’s fixed-price menu matches it. Franco Manca does a lunch pizza and a drink for £12.50.
Do I need to book Italian restaurants in Brighton?
For Cin Cin, Tutto, Semola, and Franco’s Osteria, yes. Fatto a Mano is mostly walk-in, so expect queues on Friday and Saturday evenings, though North Laine takes online bookings for groups of up to 16. The larger restaurants like Donatello and Al Duomo usually have space.
Are Pinocchio and Donatello the same?
Same family, different restaurants. Both owned by the Addis family. Pietro Addis, who came to Brighton from Sardinia, opened Pinocchio in 1987 and Donatello in 1991. His sons Leo, Stefano, and Mikele run both now.